This blog is dedicated to preserving the natural beauty of the Upper North Tyne Valley and protecting the environment
Saturday, 26 May 2012
DEVELOPMENT OF LANEHEAD
Coming soon to a field near you?
You might have assumed that living in a national park it couldn’t happen, but as the site at Lanehead so clearly shows, and as others elsewhere have been discovering, it can and does happen in spite of the legal protection for the Park’s ‘special qualities’. So as yet another newspaper report about the development here indicts the community for petty vindictiveness because of its objection to yet another planning application on the same site, and appears to present a hard-done-by image of the developer, it must be time to make it clear that this interpretation rather misses the point.
If anyone feels hard-done-by it is surely those residents who suddenly find their hitherto peaceful existence in a beautiful place facing a future of being permanently overlooked, and having their home lives disturbed by the constant comings and goings of a visitor facility. The decision to allow a tourism business on a green field site, in the very midst of a small residential settlement, was made by a totally unaccountable planning inspector as a result of an appeal. Just one person was able to over-throw all objections, including the Park’s own, effectively junking Park policy. This raises all kinds of questions, not least about a government that continues to operate a system that can override statutory obligations and democratic process without even blushing.
Further, if this can happen within a national park, which is by statute required to protect the special qualities of its environment, what hope is there for green belts or special environments anywhere in the country? There are similar cases of the dismissal of legitimate community anxieties popping up everywhere, and it is an irony that the first Lanehead appeal was being decided ( and seemingly maladministered, just to add insult to injury) at a time when localism was being trumpeted by ministers as the ‘next big idea’. To trivialise all concerned people as ‘nimbies’ is not just a cheap jibe, it shows a lack of understanding of both the acronym’s true meaning and the very genuine depth of concern being expressed.
Now that the localism process puts neighbourhood planning firmly on the agenda, and another appeal is in the offing, it will be interesting to see if the decision of Park planners and the opinions of the local community about the environment they value and love, carry any sway whatever. If, as the developer appears to expect, they are dismissed in the way they were before, it will instil an even greater urgency into the development of a neighbourhood plan. But will it be the protective layer that is needed; will it genuinely give communities more power in such decision-making? Its initial proposals gave no reason for optimism, especially as it at first intended handing over power while at the same time attempting to dictate decision outcomes - the now notorious ‘presumption in favour of sustainable development’ (i.e. we’ll let communities make their own decisions, just so long as they say ‘yes’). Only time will tell, but that’s no reason to give up on it yet and it could turn out to be the best defence against the kind of outrage recently experienced.
Anyone approaching Lanehead is already confronted by a conspicuous planning debacle, a fine contemporary design on completely the wrong site, which makes a mockery of it and of its whole context. It is a visual incongruity that has been prompting visitors who know nothing of its origination to ask if it’s a new village hall or (even) a factory. It is not unreasonable for the Tarset community to expect planning decisions, whoever makes them, to uphold the Park’s policies and statutory duties. And it should, somewhat wearily because it ought to be so obvious in an adult debate, be reiterated that none of this has anything to do with individual personalities, and everything to do with protecting the qualities of the place that is important to us all. It is a tragedy that for Lanehead this may already feel like a lost cause.
Jan Ashdown
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Aerial phot of Lanehead by kind permission of Malcolm Brodie
ReplyDeleteThis landscape has been shaped over many centuries by the needs of defence, then droving and farming, settlement and agriculture. Building has always taken place on highways, from the earliest drove roads to the more modern roads of the Victorian era and later. As the entire settlement is formed over valley side early buildings were placed where there was level land, and these two factors have largely made the patchwork landscape that is so apparent today from the air. No buildings were ever placed in the middle of a field, nor has any field been given entirely over to development until the Inspector’s decision to allow the holiday complex under 10NP0041. I remain strongly opposed to continuing development at the application site, beyond the limited infill of gaps envisioned in earlier policy documents
ReplyDelete